From Zero to One: Designing Your Team for Scale at Every Stage

From Density 2026: Reggie Williams (Sequoia), Beth Scheer (Theory Ventures) and Lisa Campbell (Town) on hiring from the first employee to 100, and why most early mistakes are over-hiring.

Neboysa Omcikus, COO at Goodfire, moderated a panel with Reggie Williams, who leads early-stage talent at Sequoia; Beth Scheer, head of talent at Theory Ventures; and Lisa Campbell, head of business at Town. They walked through the hiring journey from the first employee to 100 and beyond.

The founder is the best recruiter. Reggie said early hires join for the founder’s vision, so founders should stay in the process as long as they can. He has seen founders fly a whole team cross-country for one coffee.

The top mistake is over-hiring. Beth doesn’t mean too many people. She means hiring someone too senior for the job. A CMO excited about a Series A company without product-market fit will be bored in 3 months. Plan for the next 18 months, not 2 years out.

When to hire the first recruiter. Beth’s rule of thumb is 4 to 6 roles per recruiter per quarter, plus backfills. The first recruiter has to execute fast and set up process. Beth said the ones who struggle are often great recruiters who can’t run a process.

Learn what motivates the candidate. To close a candidate whose spouse was wary of risk, Beth’s team sent stuffed animals of the company mascot to his kids. Reggie ends calls by asking what people do outside work. Beth’s filter for Seed through Series B: candidates should say they want impact and a seat at the table.

Test the work, not the take-home. Lisa said AI has made take-homes too polished to trust. She runs short live cases on real problems, and Town uses work trials of up to a week.

Plan for scenarios, not straight lines. Reggie has founders map headcount against what-ifs, like a competitor entering their space, and tie hiring to business milestones. Beth wants a head of finance in by Series A, before equity offers get out of hand.

The closing advice: hire for the job at hand, test for motivation and adaptability, and don’t give up on a great candidate who says no.

Related Articles